Old fashion cast iron vs. enamel dutch oven

Planning on making a dutch oven purchase. There are the tradional cast iron ovens with no enamel and obviously the higher priced enamel coated versions. Why purchase an enamel over a old fashioned un-coated cast iron? Is there a value in the cooking or just ease of cleaning? Would love all opinions, will help my purchase process….

5 Answers

  • ccbweb Mar 16, 2021

    The advantages of enameled cast iron are ease of cleaning, no need to season and, biggest thing in my mind, its non-reactivity which means that its well suited for tomato based things like some chilis, soups, sauces, etc. Regular, un-coated, cast iron can react with acids especially tomatoes.

    • paulj Mar 16, 2021

      Once it is properly seasoned, non-enameled cast iron is a breeze to clean. The seasoning also protects against mild tomato sauces. While I wouldn’t use such a DO for day-long cooking of a pasta sauce, a soup or chili with a modest amount of tomato shouldn’t be a problem (but then I tend not to use tomato in my chili).

      While I have examined costly enamel DOs I suspect, price for price, a regular cast iron DO will be thicker. The thinner pan is more likely to develop hot spots. In the oven that doesn’t matter, but for high-temperature pan searing, a well seasoned cast iron is hard to beat.

      Another thing to pay attention to is the lid. For slow cooking in the oven, you want a good fit.


    • foodstorm Mar 16, 2021

      I would like to add one thing to ccbweb’s list of advantages of enameled cast iron–it’s prettier! Bare cast iron is pretty grim looking.

      • ttriche Mar 16, 2021

        Some people consider that to be a plus 😉

        For a dutch oven, however, I have to agree that enameled is the way to go.

      • peterboy Mar 16, 2021

        I cook tomato sauces and chili and lentil soup with a tomato base in my cast iron pot….not big down side that I can see.

        We have removed some unsatisfactory answers to terms and privacy.

        Leave a Reply

        Your email address will not be published.

        Related Answers

        danh bai doi thuong nhat vip go88 và yo88 go88

        sunwin tải game bài nổ hũ

        game bai rikvip doi thuong rik vip rikvip 2020